Conviction Where the signal is, and whether it pays
Most congressional trades are noise — fractional ripples and routine asset-manager rebalances. The Conviction lens filters for the opposite: a trade that is large relative to the member's own wealth, part of a cross-party cluster buying the same name, and lined up with corporate insiders (SEC Form 4) moving the same way. It is built only from facts known at filing time — other members' buys, insider trades and wealth disclosures that were already public when the trade was filed. Crucially, it is not a buy signal: right below the ranking we test, honestly, whether high-conviction buys actually beat the market more than the rest — and report whatever comes out.
Does high conviction actually pay?
| Horizon | High conviction — excess | 95% CI | n | The rest — excess | n |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 63d | -22.34% | — | 1 | -0.08% | 6937 |
| 126d | -30.69% | — | 1 | -0.11% | 5921 |
| 365d | -69.78% | — | 1 | +1.86% | 4008 |
Excess return = return above the S&P 500, measured from the filing date (look-ahead-free — what a reader could act on). "sig" marks a 95%-significant result. A hypothetical backtest on public data, not investment advice.
Highest-conviction recent buys · last 120 days
Scored 0–100 from size-vs-wealth, cluster breadth & bipartisanship, and insider convergence. Score ≥ 70 is "high conviction". Noise is filtered out first: a buy under 0.5% of the member's estimated net worth, or from a managed-account pattern (40+ small trades in 90 days), scores zero — 359 of the 409 buys in this window were filtered as noise. This is where the signal concentrates — not a recommendation.
| Conviction | Ticker | Politician | Date | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 30.0 | MBGL | Michael McCaul | 2026-08-21 | Insider convergence: SEC Form 4 insiders moved the same way (moderate) |
| 28.1 | BRK-B | Richard Dean McCormick | 2026-09-18 | Size vs wealth: ~0.7% of estimated net worth · Insider convergence: SEC Form 4 insiders moved the same way (moderate) |
| 26.5 | BRK-B | Maria Elvira Salazar | 2026-07-28 | Size vs wealth: ~1.6% of estimated net worth · Insider convergence: SEC Form 4 insiders moved the same way (weak) |
| 22.3 | EL | Jonathan Jackson | 2026-09-28 | Size vs wealth: ~2.5% of estimated net worth |
| 17.5 | SNOW | Maria Elvira Salazar | 2026-09-04 | Size vs wealth: ~1.6% of estimated net worth |
| 17.5 | MRK | Maria Elvira Salazar | 2026-08-19 | Size vs wealth: ~1.6% of estimated net worth |
| 15.1 | MSFT | Josh Gottheimer | 2026-08-14 | Size vs wealth: ~1.2% of estimated net worth |
| 10.8 | ADI | Rick Larsen | 2026-10-08 | Size vs wealth: ~0.7% of estimated net worth |
| 10.8 | WSM | Rick Larsen | 2026-10-08 | Size vs wealth: ~0.7% of estimated net worth |
| 10.1 | BRK-A | Richard Dean McCormick | 2026-07-30 | Size vs wealth: ~0.7% of estimated net worth |
| 9.0 | MU | John McGuire | 2026-10-01 | Size vs wealth: ~0.6% of estimated net worth |
| 9.0 | MU | John McGuire | 2026-09-25 | Size vs wealth: ~0.6% of estimated net worth |
| 9.0 | MU | John McGuire | 2026-09-24 | Size vs wealth: ~0.6% of estimated net worth |
| 9.0 | NVDA | John McGuire | 2026-08-18 | Size vs wealth: ~0.6% of estimated net worth |
Conviction measures the strength of the case for scrutiny and research — size, consensus, insider overlap — from information known at filing time. It is distinct from the Interest Score (which flags governance risk) and is never a prediction of returns. Not affiliated with the US government. Not investment advice.